Grab and change it, it's yours
Apr. 13th, 2011 09:29 amDoes anyone know what the actual text which is actually going to appear on the actual ballot papers on May 5th is? A bit of googling hasn't turned up any results for me, but the pages I was finding suggest to me that I may have been going about my searching in the wrong way.
I'm kind of assuming that the ballot paper will look broadly like this:
[Poll #1729575]
Now, lots of campaigners would have you believe that this is analogous to:
[Poll #1729576]
And lots of other campaigners would have you believe it's analogous to:
[Poll #1729577]
You'll notice that the second two polls allow the results to be interpreted as pol(l)ar opposites.
So, does anyone know exactly what the question is? More to the point, has the government made any commitment at all about what they're going to do with the results, how they'll be interpreted, or whether Cameron will (in fact) go "oh, that's nice" and carry on regardless with the existing system?
I'm kind of assuming that the ballot paper will look broadly like this:
[Poll #1729575]
Now, lots of campaigners would have you believe that this is analogous to:
[Poll #1729576]
And lots of other campaigners would have you believe it's analogous to:
[Poll #1729577]
You'll notice that the second two polls allow the results to be interpreted as pol(l)ar opposites.
So, does anyone know exactly what the question is? More to the point, has the government made any commitment at all about what they're going to do with the results, how they'll be interpreted, or whether Cameron will (in fact) go "oh, that's nice" and carry on regardless with the existing system?
no subject
Date: 2011-04-27 09:31 pm (UTC)(Although I'd like to think that the principle of the Condorcet criterion is straightforward and natural - if one considered having separate elections each between two candidates, and A beat B, and A beat C, it seems hard to argue that B or C should be the winner, not A. But it gets tricky when trying to think how this is decided and worked out in a single election...)
I see your point about the psychological issue. And I agree that tossing a coin would be the best thing to do (I also liked this comment). Hmm, thinking about it - I want AV to pass, just so I can worry people by tossing a coin as I'm making my vote :)