![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
ventaIt's Friday, and it's about 3 o'clock. It's time to go underneath the covers (with the lights out).
Following an overwhelming response last week (one person replied, they said yes) I've taken the file info out of the mp3, so your media player can't accidentally give the game away.
I always recommend listening to a cover version without knowing what or who it is, so click on the link before reading ahead...
Link to cover version expired
REM covering First We Take Manhattan, originally by Leonard Cohen.
Let me say straight away that I don't hold with the whiney "OMG they, like, ruined my special song" school of cover-attitudes. No, they didn't ruin it. I think you'll find your favourite song is right were you left it. They just produced a version which isn't as good (in your opinion) as the original.
Alexandar Burke is, in my book, allowed to churn out all the Cohen covers she wants to. I don't expect that I'm going to like them much, but I'm guessing she can cope with that. I'm a big fan of Leonard Cohen, I'm probably always going to prefer his songs sung by him (with the possible exception of Mr Buckley's version of Hallelujah).
So, is this cover of First We Take Manhattan as good as the original? No, says the gospel according to Venta, it is not. It is, however, different and interesting (especially in the vocal department) and I deem it worthy of a couple of careful listens.
Following an overwhelming response last week (one person replied, they said yes) I've taken the file info out of the mp3, so your media player can't accidentally give the game away.
I always recommend listening to a cover version without knowing what or who it is, so click on the link before reading ahead...
Link to cover version expired
REM covering First We Take Manhattan, originally by Leonard Cohen.
Let me say straight away that I don't hold with the whiney "OMG they, like, ruined my special song" school of cover-attitudes. No, they didn't ruin it. I think you'll find your favourite song is right were you left it. They just produced a version which isn't as good (in your opinion) as the original.
Alexandar Burke is, in my book, allowed to churn out all the Cohen covers she wants to. I don't expect that I'm going to like them much, but I'm guessing she can cope with that. I'm a big fan of Leonard Cohen, I'm probably always going to prefer his songs sung by him (with the possible exception of Mr Buckley's version of Hallelujah).
So, is this cover of First We Take Manhattan as good as the original? No, says the gospel according to Venta, it is not. It is, however, different and interesting (especially in the vocal department) and I deem it worthy of a couple of careful listens.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2010-01-22 03:57 pm (UTC)The Cohen version is not at all what I'd expected. Having now heard both I'd say that I prefer REM, but that there's an awesome epic version of this song still waiting to be recorded. Unless it's the Jennifer Warne version.
Found it http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvmt2TeI_2w
It's not. Although I think I do recognise this.