Valium hamster lives in a dreamworld, in a cage of his own

[venta]

Well, the hard-drive mentioned in the last post is not looking what you'd call well. Sysadmin #1 has thus far failed to extract anything but melodious beeps from it. Oh, and the odd crunching noise.

Best guess so far is that something has caused the platters to stick, and the inevitable bad shit has ensued. Delicate shaking and tapping have so far failed to free things up; I believe out-and-out brutality is next on the agenda.

Apparently this is a common failure with Maxtor HDs. I didn't know that, and reckon I bought it under the advice of grumblesmurf some years ago. Interestingly, Maxtor apparently claim that their HDs don't bleep, and that it's your PC you're hearing. This is demonstrably a total lie.

So, while not wishing to seem unduly pessimistic, I wondered if anyone wanted to recommend a storage solution to me ?

What do I need... Blimey, HDs have come down in price since I last bought one. So let's assume that size isn't really an issue. The fjord-pining HD was 120Gb and I don't think it was more than half full.

Primarily I listen to mp3s at work (I have the real CDs at home), so I need something that'll plug into my work laptop via USB. If anyone's got any opinions on the virtues of things sold as USB drives (like the Western Digital MyBook) versus just buying a HD and a USB caddy for it, please speak up.

Also, any specific recommendations of makes to go for or to avoid ? Maxtor have incurred my wrath; the caddy also came from what turned out to be a well-dodgy retailer on eBay. It was extremely shoddy, had no ventilation, and an illegal plug, so I won't be doing that again.

And the knotty subject of back-ups. Yes, stable doors, etc. But faced with the task of ripping hundreds of CDs I don't want to do it again again. To me it makes sense to have two HDs, one at home and one at work, thus allowing each to use the other to back up files of all kinds. My home PC is also a laptop, so will probably want some form of external HD as well - but the question is how to transfer easily between them.

Obviously I can, once I've ripped my music, transfer the bulk of it all in one fell swoop. But if I'm adding files to both my home and work HDs, I'll want to do some form of incremental copying of changes in both directions. On the whole, my two laptops are never awake at the same time, and if they were I have no idea how to access one from the other, which makes any form of over-the-air transfer a bit painful. My work laptop goes home each day, so could perhaps transfer some sort of patch in each direction ?

Is this a problem already solved ? My own scripting skills are a bit rubbish, so it might be beyond me to roll my own. Or is there a better approach to ensure I can store masses of files at work, small amounts of files at home, and be reasonably backed up ?

Comments

[venta.livejournal.com]

Hardware: good point. The last HD came out of my desktop machine at my old place of employment so was a "normal" size. I hadn't considered that I could look at other sizes.


Software: rsync would do the job, but I've no idea how to get the two machines to talk to each other.

[undyingking.livejournal.com]

If they're never both on at the same time, then I suspect you're going to have to use your work laptop as a third copy, which can be synced with both of them. I don't know of a way that you can use it just as a rolling increment.

Or use an online backup as suggested by bateleur -- I also use JungleDisk, but not for MP3s as it would be rather costly. But there are eg. free things that use a GMail account as an online storage device.

[broadmeadow.livejournal.com]

I also have an external drive at work for my music collection. It is 2.5" and USB-powered and looks very much like this one: http://www.ebuyer.com/product/113876. In order to protect against failure I go for multiple copies; the master copy is on my home PC and the work copy is a backup. To sync between the drives I use robocopy from Microsoft's Windows Server 2003 Resource Kit Tools (also suitable for XP; downloadable from http://www.microsoft.com/Downloads/details.aspx?FamilyID=9d467a69-57ff-4ae7-96ee-b18c4790cffd&displaylang=en) which, like rsync, only copies files it needs to (robocopy /mir srcdir\ tgtdir\ does the trick). To actually make the copy means taking the drive home from work to do it.